top of page

Top 10 Christmas Carols

11 minutes ago
7 min read

Well, here we are again. The holiday season is upon us, Christmas is approaching, and that means decorations, presents, Christmas music, holiday movies, and, of course, another version of Charles Dickens' A Christmas Carol.


And I mean that literally, because Johnny Depp is the latest actor to take on the role of Ebenezer Scrooge in a new adaptation called Ebenezer.


At this point, I think just about every actor who has ever lived has played Scrooge, or some variation of him, and if they haven't, just give them a few years. They'll get around to it. But with another interpretation of this legendary story on the way, I thought it would be fun to look back at my ten favorite film and television adaptations of one of the most beloved and endlessly reinvented pieces of literature ever written.


Charles Dickens published A Christmas Carol in December of 1843, and more than 180 years later, we're still telling the same story. Generations of readers, theatergoers, movie audiences and television viewers have grown up with Ebenezer Scrooge, Bob Cratchit, Tiny Tim, Jacob Marley and those three Christmas spirits.


Everybody knows A Christmas Carol. The man's name has become part of our everyday vocabulary. Call somebody a Scrooge and you don't have to explain what you mean. That's a pretty remarkable achievement for a fictional character created in Victorian England.


Dickens, born in 1812, was one of the great novelists and social commentators of the 19th century, and his own experiences with poverty and hardship profoundly influenced his writing. As a child, he was forced to work in a factory while his father was imprisoned for debt, and that experience helped shape his concern with class inequality and the treatment of the poor.


Those themes are central to A Christmas Carol, which is much more than a sentimental holiday story about a grumpy old man learning to be nice. It's a passionate condemnation of greed and selfishness, wrapped inside a wonderfully entertaining supernatural tale. It's funny, frightening, emotional, angry and ultimately enormously uplifting.


And what a great story it is. Ebenezer Scrooge is a miserable, bitter old miser who hates Christmas and seems determined to make everybody around him just as unhappy as he is.


Then, on Christmas Eve, he's visited by the ghost of his former business partner, Jacob Marley, who warns him that he's headed for a pretty miserable eternity unless he changes his ways. That leads to visits from the Ghosts of Christmas Past, Present and Yet to Come, who force Scrooge to confront the mistakes he's made, the people he's hurt and the terrible future awaiting him.


By Christmas morning, he's a changed man, filled with generosity, compassion and a renewed appreciation for life. It's a beautiful story about redemption, forgiveness and second chances, and the possibility that even the most damaged human being can change.


Who doesn't love that idea?


The story became a sensation almost immediately, with stage productions appearing within weeks of its publication. Dickens himself became famous for his public readings, beginning in 1853, essentially turning A Christmas Carol into a theatrical event long before movies or television existed.


Since then, there have been plays, musicals, operas, ballets, radio dramas, animated specials, television movies and theatrical films. The earliest surviving film adaptation dates back to 1901, a short silent production called Scrooge, or, Marley's Ghost. So filmmakers have been adapting Dickens for well over a century, and apparently nobody has any intention of stopping.


And here in Chicago, A Christmas Carol is practically an institution. For many people, the holiday season doesn't officially begin until they've attended the Goodman Theatre's annual production, a beloved tradition that has been entertaining audiences for decades. I love that families return year after year, parents introduce their children to the story, and eventually those children grow up and bring their own kids.


That's the kind of tradition that makes theater special, and it's a perfect example of how Dickens' story continues to connect with people across generations.


I've also always been fascinated by the sheer number of ways people have adapted A Christmas Carol, particularly on television. When I was growing up, just about every popular series had a Christmas episode, and one of my favorite traditions was when a regular show decided to do its own version of Dickens.


Remember The Odd Couple episode "Scrooge Gets an Oscar," where Felix and the poker players turn into Dickens characters to haunt Oscar Madison? I loved that one.


Bewitched did its own variation, Little House on the Prairie worked the story into Walnut Grove, and The Six Million Dollar Man actually gave us "A Bionic Christmas Carol." Think about that. Steve Austin using his bionic abilities to teach somebody the true meaning of Christmas. That's fantastic.


WKRP in Cincinnati, Alice, Family Ties, Fame, Mr. Belvedere and even General Hospital got into the act. If you had a television series and a character who was selfish, cranky or miserable, eventually somebody was going to send three ghosts after them.


But one of my absolute favorites was Sanford and Son, with the episode "Ebenezer Sanford." Fred Sanford, played by the magnificent Redd Foxx, is essentially Ebenezer Scrooge anyway, so adapting Dickens to that show was a perfect fit.


Fred gets visited by Christmas spirits, and I still remember Lamont appearing as one of the ghosts and screaming, "Come with me!" It absolutely cracked me up. That's the genius of Dickens' original premise. You can put it into almost any setting, with almost any characters, and it still works.


And let's talk about something that occasionally gets overlooked: A Christmas Carol is a ghost story. A genuinely scary ghost story. We tend to think of it as this warm, sentimental Christmas classic, but Dickens included some incredibly disturbing imagery.


Jacob Marley dragging those enormous chains, the mysterious spirits appearing in the middle of the night, the visions of death and suffering, and that terrifying, silent Ghost of Christmas Yet to Come.


That's some pretty creepy stuff! When I was a kid, certain versions genuinely frightened me, particularly that final spirit, who looks like the Grim Reaper showing up to tell you that your life has been a complete waste. Merry Christmas, everybody!


And because I'm a horror fan, I have a special appreciation for adaptations that embrace that darkness. The 2019 BBC/FX version starring Guy Pearce is a perfect example. It's a bleak, Gothic, genuinely unsettling interpretation that leans heavily into the psychological horror and supernatural elements.


Pearce is fantastic as a particularly damaged and unpleasant Scrooge, and the whole production has a disturbing atmosphere that separates it from the more traditional versions. It isn't necessarily the one you'd show a room full of little kids on Christmas Eve, but if you're looking for a darker, more adult interpretation, it's terrific.


Of course, the traditional adaptations are classics for a reason. The 1951 British production Scrooge, starring Alastair Sim, is probably my favorite straightforward version. Sim is magnificent, capturing the bitterness, cruelty, vulnerability and eventual joy of Ebenezer Scrooge better than just about anybody.


I also have a tremendous affection for the 1984 television film starring George C. Scott, because I love George C. Scott in just about everything. What an actor! He brings extraordinary intelligence and emotional depth to the role.


Patrick Stewart is equally impressive in the excellent 1999 adaptation, drawing on his years of performing the story as a one-man theatrical presentation. And I have to include the 1935 Scrooge, starring Seymour Hicks, one of the earliest feature-length sound versions.


Hicks had been playing the character for decades, including in a silent film back in 1913, and there's something fascinating about watching an actor with that much history in the role.


Then there are the versions that take the material in completely different directions. I absolutely love the 1970 musical Scrooge, starring Albert Finney, one of my favorite actors of all time. Finney is wonderful, the songs are memorable, and the whole production is colorful and enormously entertaining.


And how can you not love The Muppet Christmas Carol from 1992? Michael Caine plays Scrooge completely straight while surrounded by Kermit the Frog, Miss Piggy, Gonzo and the rest of the Muppets. It's funny, charming, surprisingly faithful to Dickens and genuinely touching. Caine treating the material with absolute seriousness makes the whole thing even funnier.


For something more contemporary and sarcastic, there's Scrooged from 1988, starring Bill Murray as a cynical television executive who gets his own supernatural Christmas intervention. I love that movie. It's dark, funny, wonderfully mean-spirited in places, and features a terrific cast, including a particularly lovely Karen Allen.


And then there's Blackadder's Christmas Carol, also from 1988, with the brilliant Rowan Atkinson turning the entire premise upside down with the savage wit and absurdity that made that series so great. Atkinson is one of the finest comic performers of his generation, and the special is an absolute delight.


And I certainly haven't forgotten animation. There have been terrific versions over the years, from Mister Magoo's Christmas Carol to Mickey's Christmas Carol, but one I particularly love is the 1997 animated A Christmas Carol, featuring the voice of the great Tim Curry as Scrooge.


Curry is such a marvelous performer, with that unmistakable voice and his wonderful ability to make even the nastiest characters entertaining. The production also features Whoopi Goldberg, Michael York and Ed Asner, and it's a charming addition to the enormous collection of animated Dickens adaptations.


So, with Christmas approaching and another Scrooge arriving on our screens, here are ten versions of A Christmas Carol that I particularly love. Some are faithful adaptations, others are musicals, comedies or animation, and naturally, there's one that's creepy enough to satisfy the horror fan in me.


They're all worth seeking out, and I've included trailers or clips so you can get a taste of what makes each one special.


I'm not ranking them, because I enjoy these adaptations for different reasons. Sometimes I want the magnificent Alastair Sim. Sometimes I want George C. Scott or Patrick Stewart.


Sometimes I want Bill Murray being a complete bastard, Rowan Atkinson turning Dickens upside down, or Michael Caine having a perfectly serious conversation with a bunch of Muppets.


And sometimes I want a Christmas ghost story that's scary enough to make me leave the lights on.


So, pour yourself some eggnog, get comfortable, and enjoy my ten favorite film and television adaptations of Charles Dickens' A Christmas Carol, presented in no particular order. Bah, humbug! And Merry Christmas!


MY 10 FAVORITE CHRISTMAS CAROL ADAPTATIONS (in no particular order):















Thanks for reading, and please SUBSCRIBE to my weekly NEWSLETTER!







bottom of page